Ex) Article Title, Author, Keywords
Current Optics
and Photonics
Ex) Article Title, Author, Keywords
Curr. Opt. Photon. 2023; 7(2): 136-146
Published online April 25, 2023 https://doi.org/10.3807/COPP.2023.7.2.136
Copyright © Optical Society of Korea.
Feng Li1 , Yulong Tang2, Qingsong Peng1, Guosheng Hu1
Corresponding author: *l_f200279@sina.com, ORCID 0000-0002-4767-3697
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Based on calculations using the macroscopic Maxwell’s equations with mesoscopic boundary conditions, light absorption by a layered metal-insulator-metal (MIM) metamaterial system embedded in three different environments is investigated. Increasing the top metal thickness shifts the broad absorption band to lower dielectric-constant regions and longer wavelengths, for either TM or TE waves. Boosting the dielectric-layer thickness redshifts the broadband absorption to regions of larger dielectric constant. In air, for the dielectric-constant range of 0.86–3.40, the absorption of the system exceeds 98% across 680–1,033 nm. In seawater with optimized dielectric constant, ≥94% light absorption over 400–1,200 nm can be achieved; particularly in the wavelength range of 480–960 nm and dielectric-constant range of 0.82–3.50, the absorption is greater than 98%. In an environment with even higher refractive index (1.74), ≥98% light absorption over 400–1,200 nm can be achieved, giving better performance. The influence of angle of incidence on light absorption of the MIM system is also analyzed, and the angle tolerance for ≥90% broadband absorption of a TM wave is up to 40° in an environment with large refractive index. While the incident-angle dependence of the absorption of a TE wave is nearly the same for different circumstances, the situation is different for a TM wave.
Keywords: Broadband absorption, Metamaterial, Polarized wave, Refractive index
OCIS codes: (160.3918) Metamaterials; (260.5430) Polarization; (310.1210) Antireflection coatings; (310.6860) Thin films, optical properties
In recent years, the use of compact metamaterials configured to achieve perfect electromagnetic wave absorption has aroused widespread research interest. However, multidimensional and multishape nanoplasmonic design requires complicated fabrication processes, posing a great challenge to achieve high-performance, large-area optical absorbers in the visible spectral range. As a result, scholars have turned their attention to designing large-area devices with simple production processes, the most prominent structure being the metal-insulator (MI) double-layer configuration [1]. In a metal-insulator-metal (MIM) chamber or metal-insulator-metal-insulator (MIMI) cavity, the ultrathin metal top layer develops an electromagnetic field resonance that matches the surface impedance, which is beneficial for reducing reflection and improving light absorption; the dielectric middle layer forms a Fabry-Pérot cavity, and thus improves absorption (high field intensity); and the thick bottom layer effectively blocks the propagation of electromagnetic waves and reduces light transmission [2-4]. Shu
To further the perfect-absorption features of layered metamaterial systems, other modified MIM structures have also been designed. Chen
Typically, photonic and plasmonic systems are classically described based on the local, internal dielectric function (or conductance) of the material, and the geometry and shape of the structure [10-12]. Nevertheless, when the characteristic size of metal nanostructures is in the nanometer range (especially from 10 to 20 nm), the accuracy of description by traditional classical electromagnetism decreases, due to nonlocal and quantum effects [12-17]. To solve the dilemma, mesoscopic forms of quantum nanoplasmas are introduced, and the Feibelman
In this work, we analyze the light absorption and transmission characteristics of the MIM structure under three different circumstances [air, seawater, and an environment with large refractive index (RI)] by using the nonclassical Fresnel reflection-coefficient calculation under the
Figure 1 shows the schematic diagram of the MIM system. The top and bottom metals are the same. The top metal layer excites the electric and magnetic resonances, and matches its impedance to the surrounding environment to reduce light reflection. The intermediate dielectric layer forms a F-P resonator, confining the light field and thus helping to improve the light absorption. The bottom metal layer functions to block the propagation of electromagnetic waves. The thicknesses of the top thin metal layer, the intermediate dielectric layer, and the bottom thick metal layer are expressed as
For TM (or TE)-polarization waves, the
Here
Regardless of the external charge and current, the normal macroscopic dynamic boundary conditions at the interface of two media are
For MIM systems, at the interfaces of zones 0–1 and 1–2 the boundary conditions for the parallel and vertical interfaces of electromagnetic fields are utilized:
Here the value of
According to the boundary conditions, the reflection coefficient
Here
TE waves are incident upon the MIM system, and the reflection coefficient
where r′11 = 1 + 2
In the above equations
In this work, adopting titanium as the metal, we discuss the polarized-wave absorption of the MIM system in three different environments: Air, seawater, and an environment with RI of 1.74. First, we analyze the absorption characteristics (maximum absorption Amax ≥ 98%) of the system, as a function of the thickness of the top metal layer and the dielectric constant of the intermediate dielectric layer, when the system is put in air. Second, the absorption features of the system are calculated when it is embedded in seawater. Next, the absorption characteristics of the system are discussed when it is placed in an environment with a larger RI of 1.74. Finally, we discuss the effect of incidence angle on the absorption of different polarized waves in different environments.
When the system is placed in air and the thickness of the intermediate dielectric layer is kept constant, the TM-wave absorption characteristics of the system as a function of the metal-layer thickness and the dielectric-layer dielectric constant are shown in Figs. 2(a)–2(c).
When the thickness of the top metal remains unchanged and the thickness of the dielectric layer is varied, the absorption characteristics of the system are shown in Figs. 2(d)–2(f), and are very different from the case of changing the thickness of the top metal layer. When the thickness of the dielectric layer increases from 30 to 50 to 70 nm, the high-absorption parameter space expands significantly: Not only does the high-absorption region shift to longer wavelengths, but also the dielectric constant corresponding to
We also analyze the wide-spectrum absorption response of the system to a TE-polarized wave, and find that the absorption characteristics are almost identical to that for the TM wave. When the thickness of the intermediate dielectric layer remains unchanged and the thickness of the top metal is taken as 10, 15, and 20 nm, the results for the TE-polarized wave are very similar to those in Figs. 2(a)–2(c). When the thickness of the top metal layer is unchanged and the thickness of the dielectric layer increases from 30 to 70 nm, the results for the TE-polarized wave are similar to those in Figs. 2(d)–2(f).
From the above analysis, we find that when light is incident perpendicular to the MIM system, broadband light absorption can be realized and the absorption is polarization-independent. This indicates that such MIM systems can function as ideal perfect absorbers. In actual operation, for high absorption of TM waves a moderate real part and large imaginary part should be guaranteed, while for high absorption of TE waves a moderate imaginary part and large real part should be fulfilled. Here we have achieved high absorption of both TM and TE waves, and determined the dielectric-constant region of the intermediate dielectric layer for achieving ≥94% light absorption over a wide spectral range.
Placing the system in seawater, we also analyze the light-absorption response of the system, and find that the surrounding environment has a significant impact on absorption. As shown in Figs. 3(a)–3(c), when the intermediate dielectric-layer thickness is kept unchanged and the top metal thickness is 10, 15, and 20 nm respectively, the dielectric-constant range for achieving
As shown in Figs. 3(d)–3(f), when the thickness of the top metal layer is kept at 15 nm and the thickness of the dielectric layer increases from 30 to 70 nm, not only does the dielectric constant for broadband
After analyzing the wide-spectrum absorption response of the system for a TM wave in seawater, we calculate the TE-wave absorption of the system, and find that the absorption behaviors are very similar. When the dielectric thickness is unchanged, as the top metal layer increases, the wide-spectrum absorption maximum shifts towards lower dielectric constant and longer wavelength [see Figs. 3(a)–3(c)]. This is the same as the spectral response for TE-polarization waves incident from the air to the system, except that the dielectric-constant range and wavelength range corresponding to
We further analyze the light-absorption response of the system when it is placed in an environment with large RI. It is also found that the RI of the surrounding environment plays an important role in the system’s absorption. As shown in Figs. 4(a)–4(c), when the intermediate dielectric-layer thickness is kept at 60 nm and the top metal thickness is 15 nm, the wavelength range for achieving
With finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) solutions, we obtain the light-absorption distribution at a fixed wavelength (
We further calculate the light absorption of the MIM system under different angles of incidence for a TM wave, when the system is put in air and seawater, and the results are shown in Fig. 6. As can be seen, under small incident angles (<15° in air and <30° in seawater) the system experiences strong absorption over a wide spectral range; With increasing incident angle, light absorption decreases significantly, which is similar to what is reported in the literature [6].
For incidence from air at a small angle (0° to 33°), absorption decreases over a wide spectral range as the thickness of the top metal increases [see Figs. 6(a)–6(c)]. In seawater, when the thickness of the top metal increases to 20 nm, at small angles the wave absorption is significantly reduced in the range of 400–580 nm [see Fig. 6(f)]. Comparing Figs. 6(a) and 6(d), for small incident angles the system has strong absorption over a wide spectral scope for both environments. Absorption decreases as the angle of incidence increases, and strong absorption has a larger incident-angle range at shorter wavelengths than at longer. Putting the system in a higher-index environment (seawater) helps to attain high absorption over a larger incident-angle range (30°) than that in a lower-index environment (air), and the high-absorption wavelength range is also much broader in the former case.
Unlike TM waves, when TE waves are considered, light absorption by the MIM system does not show an obvious dependence on its environment, and each polarization shows similar light-absorption dependence on incident angle (see Fig. 7). What’s interesting is that in the short-wavelength region (from 416–590 nm), TE waves can be strongly absorbed (≥90%) by the system over a large incident-angle range (up to 65°), as indicated in Fig. 6(a). In addition, for TE waves at small incident angles, the absorption decreases gradually with increasing wavelength, but when the angle of incidence exceeds 50° the absorption shows negligible dependence on wavelength, and uniform low absorption is maintained over a wide spectral region.
From the above analysis, it is found that polarized waves can be highly absorbed by the MIM system when the incidence angle is small, whether the system is put in air or seawater, and the absorption decreases with increasing incident angle. The absorption behavior of the system put in air is consistent with results in the literature [5]. While the TM-wave absorption of the system exhibits strong environmental dependence, the TE-wave absorption shows negligible dependence. Comparing Eqs. (5) and (6), where environmental influence is included in the factors of
Based on electromagnetic wave calculations under the
Whether in air or seawater, when the thickness of the top metal layer increases, the high-absorption
Finally, we have also analyzed the effects of angle of incidence on absorption in different environments. The environment has a greater effect on the correlation of absorption and incident angle for a TM wave than for a TE wave. Increasing incident angle results in reduced absorption, significant attenuation of which occurs at a smaller angle in air than in seawater. In addition, strong absorption of shorter-wavelength bands can be achieved over a wider range of incident angles than for longer-wavelength bands.
Such MIM systems are lithography-free and have simple fabrication processes, and have excellent optical absorption properties for either type of polarized wave. Thus they will not only provide a new type of light-harvesting systems, but also will give some clues for designing new layered metamaterial devices that can enhance the control of light propagation and absorption.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Data underlying the results presented in this paper are not publicly available at the time of publication, but may be obtained from the authors upon reasonable request.
Natural Science Foundation of Shanghai (China, No. 19ZR1427100); the National Natural Science Foundation of China (61306072, 61675129); the Technique Foundation of Shanghai Technical Institute of Electronics & Information (HX-22-TX034).
Curr. Opt. Photon. 2023; 7(2): 136-146
Published online April 25, 2023 https://doi.org/10.3807/COPP.2023.7.2.136
Copyright © Optical Society of Korea.
Feng Li1 , Yulong Tang2, Qingsong Peng1, Guosheng Hu1
1School of Communication and Information Engineering, Shanghai Technical Institute of Electronics & Information, Shanghai 201411, China
2Key Laboratory for Laser Plasmas (MOE), School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, China
Correspondence to:*l_f200279@sina.com, ORCID 0000-0002-4767-3697
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Based on calculations using the macroscopic Maxwell’s equations with mesoscopic boundary conditions, light absorption by a layered metal-insulator-metal (MIM) metamaterial system embedded in three different environments is investigated. Increasing the top metal thickness shifts the broad absorption band to lower dielectric-constant regions and longer wavelengths, for either TM or TE waves. Boosting the dielectric-layer thickness redshifts the broadband absorption to regions of larger dielectric constant. In air, for the dielectric-constant range of 0.86–3.40, the absorption of the system exceeds 98% across 680–1,033 nm. In seawater with optimized dielectric constant, ≥94% light absorption over 400–1,200 nm can be achieved; particularly in the wavelength range of 480–960 nm and dielectric-constant range of 0.82–3.50, the absorption is greater than 98%. In an environment with even higher refractive index (1.74), ≥98% light absorption over 400–1,200 nm can be achieved, giving better performance. The influence of angle of incidence on light absorption of the MIM system is also analyzed, and the angle tolerance for ≥90% broadband absorption of a TM wave is up to 40° in an environment with large refractive index. While the incident-angle dependence of the absorption of a TE wave is nearly the same for different circumstances, the situation is different for a TM wave.
Keywords: Broadband absorption, Metamaterial, Polarized wave, Refractive index
In recent years, the use of compact metamaterials configured to achieve perfect electromagnetic wave absorption has aroused widespread research interest. However, multidimensional and multishape nanoplasmonic design requires complicated fabrication processes, posing a great challenge to achieve high-performance, large-area optical absorbers in the visible spectral range. As a result, scholars have turned their attention to designing large-area devices with simple production processes, the most prominent structure being the metal-insulator (MI) double-layer configuration [1]. In a metal-insulator-metal (MIM) chamber or metal-insulator-metal-insulator (MIMI) cavity, the ultrathin metal top layer develops an electromagnetic field resonance that matches the surface impedance, which is beneficial for reducing reflection and improving light absorption; the dielectric middle layer forms a Fabry-Pérot cavity, and thus improves absorption (high field intensity); and the thick bottom layer effectively blocks the propagation of electromagnetic waves and reduces light transmission [2-4]. Shu
To further the perfect-absorption features of layered metamaterial systems, other modified MIM structures have also been designed. Chen
Typically, photonic and plasmonic systems are classically described based on the local, internal dielectric function (or conductance) of the material, and the geometry and shape of the structure [10-12]. Nevertheless, when the characteristic size of metal nanostructures is in the nanometer range (especially from 10 to 20 nm), the accuracy of description by traditional classical electromagnetism decreases, due to nonlocal and quantum effects [12-17]. To solve the dilemma, mesoscopic forms of quantum nanoplasmas are introduced, and the Feibelman
In this work, we analyze the light absorption and transmission characteristics of the MIM structure under three different circumstances [air, seawater, and an environment with large refractive index (RI)] by using the nonclassical Fresnel reflection-coefficient calculation under the
Figure 1 shows the schematic diagram of the MIM system. The top and bottom metals are the same. The top metal layer excites the electric and magnetic resonances, and matches its impedance to the surrounding environment to reduce light reflection. The intermediate dielectric layer forms a F-P resonator, confining the light field and thus helping to improve the light absorption. The bottom metal layer functions to block the propagation of electromagnetic waves. The thicknesses of the top thin metal layer, the intermediate dielectric layer, and the bottom thick metal layer are expressed as
For TM (or TE)-polarization waves, the
Here
Regardless of the external charge and current, the normal macroscopic dynamic boundary conditions at the interface of two media are
For MIM systems, at the interfaces of zones 0–1 and 1–2 the boundary conditions for the parallel and vertical interfaces of electromagnetic fields are utilized:
Here the value of
According to the boundary conditions, the reflection coefficient
Here
TE waves are incident upon the MIM system, and the reflection coefficient
where r′11 = 1 + 2
In the above equations
In this work, adopting titanium as the metal, we discuss the polarized-wave absorption of the MIM system in three different environments: Air, seawater, and an environment with RI of 1.74. First, we analyze the absorption characteristics (maximum absorption Amax ≥ 98%) of the system, as a function of the thickness of the top metal layer and the dielectric constant of the intermediate dielectric layer, when the system is put in air. Second, the absorption features of the system are calculated when it is embedded in seawater. Next, the absorption characteristics of the system are discussed when it is placed in an environment with a larger RI of 1.74. Finally, we discuss the effect of incidence angle on the absorption of different polarized waves in different environments.
When the system is placed in air and the thickness of the intermediate dielectric layer is kept constant, the TM-wave absorption characteristics of the system as a function of the metal-layer thickness and the dielectric-layer dielectric constant are shown in Figs. 2(a)–2(c).
When the thickness of the top metal remains unchanged and the thickness of the dielectric layer is varied, the absorption characteristics of the system are shown in Figs. 2(d)–2(f), and are very different from the case of changing the thickness of the top metal layer. When the thickness of the dielectric layer increases from 30 to 50 to 70 nm, the high-absorption parameter space expands significantly: Not only does the high-absorption region shift to longer wavelengths, but also the dielectric constant corresponding to
We also analyze the wide-spectrum absorption response of the system to a TE-polarized wave, and find that the absorption characteristics are almost identical to that for the TM wave. When the thickness of the intermediate dielectric layer remains unchanged and the thickness of the top metal is taken as 10, 15, and 20 nm, the results for the TE-polarized wave are very similar to those in Figs. 2(a)–2(c). When the thickness of the top metal layer is unchanged and the thickness of the dielectric layer increases from 30 to 70 nm, the results for the TE-polarized wave are similar to those in Figs. 2(d)–2(f).
From the above analysis, we find that when light is incident perpendicular to the MIM system, broadband light absorption can be realized and the absorption is polarization-independent. This indicates that such MIM systems can function as ideal perfect absorbers. In actual operation, for high absorption of TM waves a moderate real part and large imaginary part should be guaranteed, while for high absorption of TE waves a moderate imaginary part and large real part should be fulfilled. Here we have achieved high absorption of both TM and TE waves, and determined the dielectric-constant region of the intermediate dielectric layer for achieving ≥94% light absorption over a wide spectral range.
Placing the system in seawater, we also analyze the light-absorption response of the system, and find that the surrounding environment has a significant impact on absorption. As shown in Figs. 3(a)–3(c), when the intermediate dielectric-layer thickness is kept unchanged and the top metal thickness is 10, 15, and 20 nm respectively, the dielectric-constant range for achieving
As shown in Figs. 3(d)–3(f), when the thickness of the top metal layer is kept at 15 nm and the thickness of the dielectric layer increases from 30 to 70 nm, not only does the dielectric constant for broadband
After analyzing the wide-spectrum absorption response of the system for a TM wave in seawater, we calculate the TE-wave absorption of the system, and find that the absorption behaviors are very similar. When the dielectric thickness is unchanged, as the top metal layer increases, the wide-spectrum absorption maximum shifts towards lower dielectric constant and longer wavelength [see Figs. 3(a)–3(c)]. This is the same as the spectral response for TE-polarization waves incident from the air to the system, except that the dielectric-constant range and wavelength range corresponding to
We further analyze the light-absorption response of the system when it is placed in an environment with large RI. It is also found that the RI of the surrounding environment plays an important role in the system’s absorption. As shown in Figs. 4(a)–4(c), when the intermediate dielectric-layer thickness is kept at 60 nm and the top metal thickness is 15 nm, the wavelength range for achieving
With finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) solutions, we obtain the light-absorption distribution at a fixed wavelength (
We further calculate the light absorption of the MIM system under different angles of incidence for a TM wave, when the system is put in air and seawater, and the results are shown in Fig. 6. As can be seen, under small incident angles (<15° in air and <30° in seawater) the system experiences strong absorption over a wide spectral range; With increasing incident angle, light absorption decreases significantly, which is similar to what is reported in the literature [6].
For incidence from air at a small angle (0° to 33°), absorption decreases over a wide spectral range as the thickness of the top metal increases [see Figs. 6(a)–6(c)]. In seawater, when the thickness of the top metal increases to 20 nm, at small angles the wave absorption is significantly reduced in the range of 400–580 nm [see Fig. 6(f)]. Comparing Figs. 6(a) and 6(d), for small incident angles the system has strong absorption over a wide spectral scope for both environments. Absorption decreases as the angle of incidence increases, and strong absorption has a larger incident-angle range at shorter wavelengths than at longer. Putting the system in a higher-index environment (seawater) helps to attain high absorption over a larger incident-angle range (30°) than that in a lower-index environment (air), and the high-absorption wavelength range is also much broader in the former case.
Unlike TM waves, when TE waves are considered, light absorption by the MIM system does not show an obvious dependence on its environment, and each polarization shows similar light-absorption dependence on incident angle (see Fig. 7). What’s interesting is that in the short-wavelength region (from 416–590 nm), TE waves can be strongly absorbed (≥90%) by the system over a large incident-angle range (up to 65°), as indicated in Fig. 6(a). In addition, for TE waves at small incident angles, the absorption decreases gradually with increasing wavelength, but when the angle of incidence exceeds 50° the absorption shows negligible dependence on wavelength, and uniform low absorption is maintained over a wide spectral region.
From the above analysis, it is found that polarized waves can be highly absorbed by the MIM system when the incidence angle is small, whether the system is put in air or seawater, and the absorption decreases with increasing incident angle. The absorption behavior of the system put in air is consistent with results in the literature [5]. While the TM-wave absorption of the system exhibits strong environmental dependence, the TE-wave absorption shows negligible dependence. Comparing Eqs. (5) and (6), where environmental influence is included in the factors of
Based on electromagnetic wave calculations under the
Whether in air or seawater, when the thickness of the top metal layer increases, the high-absorption
Finally, we have also analyzed the effects of angle of incidence on absorption in different environments. The environment has a greater effect on the correlation of absorption and incident angle for a TM wave than for a TE wave. Increasing incident angle results in reduced absorption, significant attenuation of which occurs at a smaller angle in air than in seawater. In addition, strong absorption of shorter-wavelength bands can be achieved over a wider range of incident angles than for longer-wavelength bands.
Such MIM systems are lithography-free and have simple fabrication processes, and have excellent optical absorption properties for either type of polarized wave. Thus they will not only provide a new type of light-harvesting systems, but also will give some clues for designing new layered metamaterial devices that can enhance the control of light propagation and absorption.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Data underlying the results presented in this paper are not publicly available at the time of publication, but may be obtained from the authors upon reasonable request.
Natural Science Foundation of Shanghai (China, No. 19ZR1427100); the National Natural Science Foundation of China (61306072, 61675129); the Technique Foundation of Shanghai Technical Institute of Electronics & Information (HX-22-TX034).